Comments URL: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49954103

Points: 1

# Comments: 0

Comments URL: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49942618

Points: 3

# Comments: 1

Maybe they can push it to make the Android accessibility framework more responsive, especially when scrolling the screen with TalkBack, and catch TalkBack up with VoiceOver. Oh and add Accessibility Actions to apps like YouTube so I don't have to swipe through "video name", "video name button", "go to channel button", "more actions button", every, single, video.

But they won't because accessibility is something you have to actually prompt the model to do and who cares about a11y.

If you're reading this, I'd like a favor. I'd like you to read the WCAG, then force all software, including that from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Apple, Microsoft, all Linux desktops and packages, especially mobile Linux stuff, oh and did I mention Google, to be accessible, compliant to the highest possible level of the WCAG. Thank you.

For non-FOSS products, it's even worse. There is no way to tell Amazon that, for the past several months, their library view for Kindle on iOS was inaccessible to VoiceOver, with the books having no accessibility label, and the only way one can tell what book they're about to open is through VoiceOver's tiny on-device image describer model. Of course, in iOS 27 (beta currently) this is improved, but it shouldn't have to be. The last few versions of Kindle has begun fixing this, but last time I tried, about a week ago, it could easily break even just by my scrolling the view a few times.

So I don't even bother anymore. If Google can stand having poor Braille support on Android, fine, I'll use an iPhone. If Apple can stand having awful Google Docs support, which I use at work, on MacOS, I'll use Windows or even Linux where it works fine. If an image isn't described, I will put it through AI. If a page doesn't work well with a screen reader, I'll send it through AI too. If I want to play a video game where 99% of them do not have spoken menus, but I can enjoy the actual gameplay, I'll ask AI which menu option I'm on.

I've come to feel that life is so miserable when I and only a few others fight and fight for accessibility. If it works, it only works for a moment. So I just lean on AI because it can "see" a lot better than I can. Besides, people have used AI to make accessibility mods for Final Fantasy 1 through 6, the pixel-remaster versions. So when terminally angry people come at me for my use of AI, I just don't care anymore. Let them go blind and see how it feels.

https://www.intheweights.com/p/devin-prater